“SHACK” AUTHOR PAUL YOUNG STATES:
“CHRIST IS ‘IN’ EVERY SINGLE HUMAN BEING”,
IN JUST RELEASED NEW BOOK
republished below in full unedited for informational, educational, and research purposes:
By Warren B. Smith
For the time will come when they will not endure
sound doctrine; But after their own lusts shall they heap to themselves
teachers, Having itching ears; And they shall turn away their ears from
the truth and shall be turned unto fables. (2 Timothy 4:3-4)
YOUNG PUBLICLY ENDORSES UNIVERSAL SALVATION
In his just-released book (March 7th), Lies We Believe About God,
best-selling author Paul Young openly describes himself as a
universalist. In chapter 13, Young would have us believe it is a “lie”
to tell someone, “You need to get saved.”1 Young asks himself the
rhetorical questions, “Are you suggesting that everyone is saved? That
you believe in universal salvation?”2 He answers, “That is exactly what I
am saying!”3 Young then goes on to teach that “every single human being
is in Christ” and that “Christ is in them.”4 With this unbiblical
teaching, one recalls how Young put these same heretical words in the
mouth of his “Jesus” character in The Shack. He wrote:
God, who is the ground of all being, dwells in, around, and through all things.5
THE TRINITARIAN LIE
Young would have us believe his trinitarian lie that God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit inherently indwell everyone.6
This is exactly what the false “Christ” of the New Age teaches. In
fact, it is the foundational teaching of the New Age/New
Spirituality/New World Religion that has progressively moved into the
world and into the church.
NEW AGE IN THE CHURCH
As I pointed out in my booklet, The Shack and Its New Age Leaven,7
the teaching that God is “in” everyone is a heretical New Age teaching
that has been increasingly popularized over the last thirty years by New
Age authors and teachers and heavily promoted by people like Oprah
Winfrey. Sadly, it is also found in the books and teachings of
well-known church figures like Robert Schuller, Rick Warren, Eugene
Peterson, Leonard Sweet, and Sarah Young.8 And in a November 1, 2016 Catholic News Service
article titled, “Pope Offers New Beatitudes for Saints of a New Age”
Pope Francis, in a Catholic Mass in Malmo, Sweden, proposed a new
“beatitude”—”Blessed are those who see God in every person and strive to
make others also discover him.”9
WHAT WILL THE CHURCH DO?
Paul Young wanted to have a conversation about the
nature of God, and that conversation is now front and center before the
church. Will pastors and leaders and day-to-day believers contend for
the faith and fight the good fight, or will they let false teachers like
Paul Young have their uncontested say and have their uncontested way?
Endnotes:
1. Chapter 13 title in Lies We Believe About God is “You need to get saved.”
2. William Paul Young, Lies We Believe About God (New York, NY: Atria Books; An imprint of Simon & Schuster, 2017), p. 118.
3. Ibid.
4. Ibid., p. 119.
5. William P. Young, The Shack (Newbury Park, CA: Windblown Media, 2007), p. 112.
6. In C. Baxter Kruger’s book, The Shack Revisited: There Is More Going On Here Than You Ever Dared to Dream, in the foreword, Shack author William Paul Young writes: I want to say, “Thank you, and please read The Shack Revisited.” He adds, “If you want to understand better the perspectives and theology that frame The Shack,
this book is for you. Baxter has taken on the incredible task of
exploring the nature and character of the God who met me in my own shack” (p. ix). On page 49 of The Shack Revisited , Kruger writes: “For inside of us all, because of Jesus, is nothing short of the very trinitarian life of God.” C. Baxter Kruger, The Shack Revisited: There Is More Going On Here than You Ever Dared to Dream (New York, NY: FaithWords), p. 49.
7. To read this booklet, click here: http://www.lighthousetrailsresearch.com/blog/?p=12290.
8. I have documented a short history of how this deceptive
New Age teaching has entered the world and the church in my booklet Be Still and Know That You Are Not God. The booklet includes quotes by each of these figures. To read this booklet, click here: http://www.lighthousetrailsresearch.com/blog/?p=17572.
9. Cathy Wooden, “Pope Offers New Beatitudes for Saints of a New Age” (Catholic News Service, November 1, 2016,).
_____________________________________________________
Fourth Letter to Christian Leaders Goes Out –
A Warning About The Shack
Lighthouse Trails has now sent out its 4th letter since early 2016 to
over 130 prominent Christian leaders. Along with the letter, we
included a copy of the booklet we publish, The Shack and Its New Age Leaven
plus a news brief we released recently. Both the booklet and the news
brief are written by former New Age follower Warren B. Smith. Here is
the letter we wrote to the leaders introducing the material:
Dear Christian Leader:
Please find enclosed one of our booklets titled The Shack and Its New Age Leaven by Lighthouse Trails author Warren B. Smith along with a short news brief we released on March 9th. As you probably know, The Shack movie came out this month, which no doubt will bring renewed interest in the book, The Shack.
When you read this booklet and the news brief, we hope you will
understand our sense of urgency given that many Christian leaders and
pastors are now endorsing The Shack. In William Paul Young’s newest book, Lies We Believe About God, he once again openly rejects biblical tenets of the Christian faith.
We hope you will read and prayerfully consider the content of both the booklet and the news brief.
Sincerely in Christ,
The Editors at
Lighthouse Trails Publishing, Inc.
The letters and booklets were mailed out from our office in Montana on March 13th. You can read the news brief we included by clicking here. And here is the link to the content of the booklet we sent.
Since we began sending out letters and booklets to Christian leaders in early 2016, we have received the following responses:
Short letters of thanks from the ministry offices of: Chuck Missler, Nancy DeMoss, Tony Evans, James Dobson, Pat Robertson, and Beth Moore
Notes of thanks personally signed by Tim Tebow, Kay Arthur, George Wood (Assemblies of God General Superintendent)
A letter of thanks via e-mail from Ben Kinchlow’s ministry manager (Kinchlow is the founder of Americans for Israel and former 700 Club host)
An e-email from the office of Chuck Swindoll telling us to stop sending booklets (we have since removed his name from our list).
It is our hope and prayer that many of the leaders on our list will take a few moments to read the material we sent out on The Shack.
If you would like us to add the name of a leader to our
Christian leaders list, please send the name and mailing address to us
at: editors@lighthousetrails.com. Because of time restraints, we will
not be able to add a name without an address. Plus, because we cannot
send out these letters and booklets to every pastor in the country,
we ask that you only submit names of pastors and/or church leaders who
have written at least one book (you can check Amazon) thus moving him
or her into a place of influence throughout the church at large.
We wish we could send booklets to every Christian pastor in
North America. However, here is an idea given to us from one of our
readers for anyone who feels compelled to reach the pastors in his or
her denomination and/or state: Last month, a woman contacted us from
Mississippi who learned that we were sending out booklets to Christian
leaders and pastors. She said she was burdened for Southern Baptist
pastors in her state and asked us to put together a mailing of two
booklets and a letter and mail it to every Southern Baptist pastor in
Mississippi. Our reader paid for the list (which we purchased for her),
the booklets, the postage, and our labor. At her request, we sent
each pastor a copy of 10 Scriptural Reasons Jesus Calling is a Dangerous Book by Warren B. Smith and 5 Things You Should Know About Contemplative Prayer by Ray Yungen. If you have a group you would like us to reach in this manner, please contact our office.
If you would like to view and/or print a list of the
Christian leaders we are currently sending booklets and short letters
to 3-4 times a year, click here.
Perhaps you would like to pray for these men and women who, in total,
influence millions and millions of people throughout the world.
Incidentally, just because a name is on this list does not necessarily
mean that leader is in deception. We have included a wide assortment of
names in this list. There are many pastors and Christian leaders who
may not be part of the deception but, for various reasons, are not
aware of what is happening in the church today.
_____________________________________________________
This is Not a Review of the “SHACK”:
BY C.H. FISHER
republished below in full unedited for informational, educational, and research purposes:
I’m not going to write a review or detailed critique of William P.
Young’s book or movie both entitled “The Shack.” The reason is because
there are already a number of good reviews available. You can access
plenty of information on Lighthouse Trails Research. What I will do is
present a warning.
First, I want to point out that there are some heresies and
deceptions that one should not need a review to recognize and reject.
The televangelist selling God’s favor, which increases with the size of
the donation, is one. Another one is a preacher smoking pot or getting
drunk on video while claiming that it is the way to get closer to God.
One more is the preacher that declares that God has entrusted only him
with new revelation essential to understanding the Bible. Likewise, does
anyone really need to inform a true Christian about what is wrong with
“The Shack”?
Now for the warning. God’s word declares that the end times will be
very dangerous for Christians. There will be many spiritually wicked
individuals masquerading as servants of God. They will present heresies
and other lies for the purpose of deceiving God’s people. However, some
professing Christians declare that it is impossible for Christians to be
deceived and apostatize. If that is true, then who is Satan deceiving
and who is apostatizing? The lost are already deceived and cannot
apostatize from faith that they do not have.
Obviously, the deception has to be very clever. If it were disguised
as an orange, it would appear exactly as a genuine orange. Therefore, we
can expect lies disguised exactly as truth. However, if people accept
enough false oranges loaded with a mind-numbing drug, it stands to
reason that false oranges will no longer be needed. Then whatever is
being disguised by the falseness will be offered without pretense.
Leading Christians accepted and promoted movies such as the “Son of
God” and “Noah”. Now professing Christians are accepting “Silence” and
“The Shack”, movies, which are more obviously wicked. Does anyone want
to know what is coming next that professing Christians might support?
William Paul Young, author of “The Shack”, wrote another book, “Eve.” Young explains about his book:
“As The Shack awakened readers to a personal, non-religious
understanding of God, Eve will free us from faulty interpretations that
have corrupted human relationships since the Garden of Eden.”
Any warning bells going off yet? If one is deceived by “The Shack”
one is probably unaware of the diabolical boasts in Young’s explanation.
Remember, this is not the author of a timeless Christian classic, but
the author of a heretical book that blasphemes the Holy Spirit.
What is it that Young intended to set us free from with “Eve”? Here are a few links in the chain of our “bondage.”
- The story of Creation is replaced by the Big Bang.
- Adam was an infant nursed by the breasts of God.
- Adam was a sinner before Eve was created.
- Adam became pregnant and gave birth to Eve.
- Adam and Satan conspired to deceive Eve.
But it gets even worse. Young has a new book entitled, “Lies We
Believe About God.” Here are some of what Young calls lies about God.
- “God wants to use me.”
- “God is in control.”
- “God is a prude.”
- “God does not submit.”
- “Hell is separation from God.”
- “Sin separates us from God.”
- “God is disappointed in me.”
If professing Christians accept the blatancy of that satanic
deception, their fate is sealed. When one of these books also becomes a
movie, professing Christians will fawn all over them and declare that
anyone that opposes them is ignorant or just plain mean-spirited.
The false orange is no longer needed. Professing Christians are
significantly deceived by number and intensity to consume the raw lies.
However, the subsequent deception does not stop with convincing them
to believe the lies. Additionally, they believe that the fact they can
so easily line up for the feast is not proof of deception. Instead, they
consider it to be evidence that they are superior in spirituality and
knowledge to the ones who refrain. Tragically, those feasting masses
can be warned, but they are unable to receive the warnings.
_______________________________________________________
When People Say, “But The Shack is Just a Novel!”
A woman standing in line outside the theater to see The Shack movie was eager to talk with me about Paul Young’s best-selling book. She said she “loved” The Shack
and couldn’t understand why it had so many critics on the Internet. She
was especially perplexed by the number of “negative” comments made by
pastors. Obviously confused by all the controversy, she suddenly
exclaimed—”But The Shack is just a novel!”
What the woman and so many other Shack
readers fail to take into account is that the book is much more than
just a novel. It is a carefully crafted presentation of Paul Young’s
alternative “Christian” universalist theology based on “real”
conversations he claims to have had with God. In Young’s forward to The Shack Revisited, a book written by his friend C. Baxter Kruger, Young corrects any misunderstanding that The Shack is “just a novel.” He writes:
Please don’t misunderstand me; The Shack is theology. But it is theology wrapped in story.1
If you want to understand better the perspectives and theology that frame The Shack,
this book [Kruger’s] is for you. Baxter has taken on the incredible
task of exploring the nature and character of the God who met me in my
own shack.2
According to Young, God came to him in the “Great Sadness” of his own “shack” and communicated directly with him. Much of The Shack’s theology is based on what Young learned in his conversations with God.
Young’s Conversations with God
A Christian news source recently reprinted
excerpts from several posts Young made on his personal blog back in
August 2007. In these excerpts, Young explained that The Shack is a story, but it is a story based on real conversations he was having with God, his friends, and his family. He writes:
Remember, I am thinking about writing
this for my kids, so I am searching for a good vehicle to communicate
through. I figure a good story would be great . . . but I didn’t have
one. So I started with what I did have . . . conversations. So, off and
on, for about three months I wrote down conversations; conversations that I was having with God mostly, but which often included friends or family.3 [emphasis added by W. Smith]
Is the story “real”? The story is
fiction. I made it up. Now, having said that, I will add that the
emotional pain with all its intensity and the process that tears into
Mack’s heart and soul are very real. I have my “shack,” the place I had
to go through to find healing. I have my Great Sadness . . . that is all
real. And the conversations are very real and true. . . .
So is the story true? The pain, the loss, the grief, the process, the conversations,
the questions, the anger, the longing, the secrets, the lies, the
forgiveness . . . all real, all true.4 [emphasis added by W. Smith]
Young’s “Christian” Universalism
In a February 16, 2008 post on a blog called Christian Universalism: The Beautiful Heresy: The Shack,
an avowed “friend” of Paul Young corroborates Young’s 2007 blog post
about his conversations with God. The friend describes how the
conversations Young’s main character Mack has with God in The Shack
are “real conversations” that Paul Young actually had with God. She
reveals how these conversations “revolutionized” Young, his family, and
friends such as herself. She says that the “radically dangerous”
teachings that Young put in his novel have become her new “systematic
theology” and The Shack is her new “systematic theology
handbook.” The following are her exact words and punctuation as they
were originally posted on the “Christian Universalism” blog:
I know the author well—a personal friend.
(Our whole house church devoured it last summer, and Paul came to our
home to discuss it—WONDERFUL time!) The conversations that “Mack” has with God, are real conversations that Paul Young had with God . . . and they revolutionized him, his family, and friends
(Paul had a very traumatic past, raised by missionary parents, who left
him in the care of the stone-age Dani tribe, while they did “God’s
work.” He was abused by them, in the process—and there were other
tragedies in his life, later on. When he was a broken mess, God began to speak to him).
He wrote the story (rather than a “sermon”) to give the real
conversations context—and because Jesus also used simple stories to
engage our hearts, even by-passing our objective brains, in order to
have His message take root in our hearts, and grow. . . .
I had already come to believe all the
“radically dangerous” teachings within this book—so it mostly confirmed
what I already believed. But, it most definitely highlighted the reality
that I don’t yet KNOW (KNOW!) how much God loves me. I want the
relationship with God that I see in Paul Young’s life. . . .
This was the first book that I read
straight through 4 times. First to absorb it. Secondly, to underline.
Third to highlight. Fourth, to put “headers” on the top of each page, so
that I could find certain passages again. It’s become my new
“systematic theology” handbook!5 [emphasis added by W. Smith]
Thus, by his own account and that of his friend, Paul Young would be the first to deny that The Shack is “just a novel.”
Young the Universalist
Back to my conversation with the woman in front of the movie theater. When she said that The Shack
was “just a novel,” I described how his novel was actually a fictional
device used as a “vehicle” for presenting some of his own misguided
theological teachings—teachings that had more in common with New Age
teachings than biblical Christianity. When she acknowledged knowing
about the New Age movement, I told her that some of The Shack’s
teachings were actually New Age teachings. But before I could explain
what those specific teachings were and how I had once been involved in
the New Age myself, the theater doors opened, the line started moving,
and our conversation was suddenly over. She seemed relieved as she
turned toward the theater and away from me. Praying that she would come
to understand that Paul Young has more in common with New Age
universalism than biblical Christianity. I had no idea at the time that
Young was about to publicly declare in a new book what so many of us
already knew. In Lies We Believe About God, which was released
on March 7th, Young states that he believes in “universal salvation”6
and that “every single human being is in Christ” and “Christ is in
them.”7 Thus, Young himself makes it very clear in his own words that The Shack
is not “just a novel” but rather a “cunningly devised fable” (2 Peter
1:16) for presenting some of his own heretical universalistic New Age
views.
Who is Paul Young Really Listening To and Conversing With?
Paul Young would have us believe that he has been having “real” conversations with God and that he was inspired by God to write The Shack. Yet
he is now declaring himself to be a universalist who believes in the
false New Age trinitarian doctrine that God, Christ, and the Holy Spirit
are already “in” everyone. In other words, Young, as a professing
universalist, would have us believe that all of humanity is already
saved (universal salvation). The question that naturally arises and
that is now before the church is—just who is Paul Young
actually listening to and conversing with? The God of the Bible or the
false “God” of the New Age?
Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that
in the latter times some depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing
spirits, and doctrines of devils. (1 Timothy 4:1)
Endnotes
1. C. Baxter Kruger, The Shack Revisited: There Is More Going on Here than You Ever Dared to Dream ( New York, NY: FaithWorks, Hatchette Book Group, 2012), p. xi.
2. Ibid., p. viiii.
3. Sunny Shell, “The Shack, a Biblical and Interactive Review” (http://blogs.christianpost.com/abandoned-to-christ/the-shack-a-biblical-and-interactive-review-28674/, posted 2/16/17, quoting Paul Young from his August 15, 2007 blog titled “The Shack
– update – Background #2″
(http://web.archive.org/web/20070911092057/http://www.windrumors.com/29/the-shack-update-background-2/).
4. Sunny Shell, “The Shack, a Biblical and Interactive Review” (http://blogs.christianpost.com/abandoned-to-christ/the-shack-a-biblical-and-interactive-review-28674/, posted 2/16/17, quoting Paul Young from his August 15, 2007 blog titled “Is the story of THE SHACK
true . . . is Mack a “real” person?
(http://web.archive.org/web/20070911092319/http://www.windrumors.com/30/is-the-story-of-the-shack-trueis-mack-a-real-person/).
5. Christian Universalism-The Beautiful Heresy: The Shack (http://web.archive.org/web/20080307051159/http://christian-universalism.blogs.com/thebeautifulheresy/2008/02/the-shack.html, posted February 16, 2008 by Dena Brehm. (Thanks to Kent McElroy for bringing this blog to my attention).
6. Wm. Paul Young, Lies We Believe About God (New York, NY: Atria Books, an Imprint of Simon & Schuster, 2017), p. 118.
7. Ibid., p. 119.
_______________________________________________________
William Paul Young (The Shack Author)
& His Connection with Panentheist Richard Rohr
LTRP Note: The Shack movie has just been
released. Millions of Americans will go to theaters to watch the movie.
Most likely, the majority of them will be church goers and proclaiming
Christians since The Shack book is vetted as a Christian story.
Recently, a church contacted Lighthouse Trails and ordered 300 copies
of Warren B. Smith’s booklet The Shack and Its New Age Leaven.
If you have family, church members, pastors, and friends who might be
considering attending this movie, please pick up some copies of the
booklet and pass them out. As you can see from the piece below by
Lighthouse Trails author Lois Putnam, William Paul Young resonates with
panentheists (God is IN all), and we know from our research that The Shack resonates with this concept too. Please do what you can to warn everyone you know. The false “Christ” of The Shack
has big plans to deceive many. If you can’t afford to buy the booklet,
you can print the content from our blog; but we believe this very inexpensive booklet is a better way to go (in a published bound format, it helps give credibility to the material and the source).
By Lois Putnam
Catholic priest and panentheist mystic Richard Rohr (along with co-author mystic emergent Mike Morrell) recently wrote the book The Divine Dance: The Trinity and Your Transformation. William
Paul Young wrote its foreword. Inside, its dedication says: “From
Richard Rohr: To all unsuspecting folks who do not know they are already
within the ‘Divine Flow’” [i.e., panentheism]. In the foreword, Young
says, “May we feel within us the eternal life of Jesus reaching through
our hands–to heal, to hold, to hug–and celebrate the bread of our
Humanity, the sanctity of the Ordinary, and Participation in the
Trinity.”
Other endorsers include Rob Bell, Brian D.
McLaren, and a host of others. As Lighthouse Trails Research points out
in “In Case You Still Aren’t Sure About the Shack and Its
Author,” perhaps Young’s “Twenty Books Everyone Should Read” will
convince you otherwise. Click onto the article here: http://www.lighthousetrailsresearch.com/blog/?p=17684
And Young, continuing his close association
with Rohr, will join him and Cynthia Bourgeault in April 6-8, 2017 to
take part in a program titled: “Trinity: The Soul of Creation”
in Albuquerque, New Mexico. Its online descriptive ad reads, “Rohr,
Bourgeault, and Young believe the Trinity . . . has the capacity to
change everything. We already participate within this dance whether we
realize it or not [that God is in everyone]. But when we consciously
engage in loving communion, we open ourselves to being transformed at
the deepest levels. Bring your heart, mind, and body to this . . .
conversation. Join an ecumenical and inter-faith gathering, moving
together through reflective experiences, including contemplative prayer,
music, movement (Yoga, Tai Chi Chin, and walking meditation), group and
individual processing. …” To read Lois Putnam’s entire article on The Shack, click here.
Note: Cynthia Bourgeault is a
name we know well at Lighthouse Trails. Ray Yungen spoke of her to us
often. She is an Episcopal priest who is a devoted advocate for
everything contemplative. Here is a list of some of her books to prove our point.
Related Articles:
Something to Think About – Richard Rohr, the New Age, and Young Evangelical Christians
IF: Gathering Leader/Pastor Melissa Greene—A Female Version of McLaren, Bell, Rohr, and Merton
Richard Foster’s Renovare Turns to Panentheist Mystic Richard Rohr and Emerging Darling Phyllis Tickle For New Book Project
_______________________________________________________
SEE OUR POST ABOUT CATHOLIC MYSTIC RICHARD ROHR:
https://ratherexposethem.org/2013/04/much-more-on-rohr-plus-enneagrams.html